The Forgotten Sister

Title:  The Forgotten Sister

Author:  Nicola Cornick

Publication Information:  Graydon House. 2020. 368 pages.

ISBN:  1525809954 / 978-1525809958

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley and through the Fall 2020 historical fiction blog tour from Harlequin Trade Publishing free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "They came for me one night in the winter of 1752 when the ice was on the pond and the trees bowed under the weight of the hoar frost."

Favorite Quote:  "Yet in the end it is your kindness that heals me. Kindness cannot alter the past but it can change the future. It can bring peace."

***** BLOG TOUR *****

Review

Amy Robsart is a historical figure from Elizabethan England. Her "claim to fame" unfortunately was her unhappy marriage and her death. She was the wife of Robert Dudley, a favorite of Elizabeth I. Amy died from a fall down a flight of stairs. The circumstances surrounding the fall were never clarified. It remains undetermined whether the death was an accident or a results of more nefarious decisions.

The book begins with a prologue from 1752. It is unclear how it ties into the story until the very end, but then it encapsulates the story and brings it to closure. The rest of the book goes between 1549 and 2020. In 1549, there are Amy, Anna, Robert, Elizabeth, Arthur, and Johnny. In 2020, there are Amelie, Anna, Dudley, Lizzie, Arthur, and Johnny. In 1549, there are court intrigues and the rise and fall of fortunes as the struggle for power continues and the control of the throne shifts. In 2020, there are celebrity lifestyles and a death which calls into question life choices. in 1549, the story centers around Amy. In 2020, it is Lizzie.

Both Amy and Lizzie's stories are also the stories of women in their own way finding their own voices and taking (or attempting to take) charge of the direction of their lives. Considering that history tells us Amy dies under suspicious circumstances tells you the conclusion of her story. Where Lizzie's story end is much more open for question as is the question of how their stories relate.

The book gives a lot of clues as to that connection - the prologue, the title of the book, the character names in the two time periods. In other words, the mystery turns out to not be such a mystery. However, in this case, it does not distract from the discovery of the mystery or the enjoyment of the book.

The magical realism in this book stems from extrasensory abilities in people. Psychometry is the supposed ability to learn about an event, a person, or other history from touching an inanimate object. Science disagrees about whether or not psychometry actually exists. This, telepathy, a ghost boy, and even time travel are foundational to this story. I choose to suspend disbelief and go along for the ride. I also do respond to the emotional use of psychometry. The thought of touching an object of a loved one who has passed away and conjuring up a scenario as if they were still there is an appealing one. Which one of us would not relish that possibility if only for a moment!

This book picks up on the history of Amy Robsart's death and develops an entire two timeline story that incorporates history, love stories, sibling rivalries, celebrity lifestyles, mysterious deaths, and magical realism. This book is unusual in two timeline stories in that I find myself equally engaged in both stories. Usually, one takes precedence, but this book finds that unique balance. The title of the book, I realize at the end, is a spoiler, but the book itself is a fast paced page turner that keeps me engaged until the very end.

About the Book

In the tradition of the spellbinding historical novels of Philippa Gregory and Kate Morton comes a stunning story based on a real-life Tudor mystery, of a curse that echoes through the centuries and shapes two women’s destinies…

1560: Amy Robsart is trapped in a loveless marriage to Robert Dudley, a member of the court of Queen Elizabeth I. Surrounded by enemies and with nowhere left to turn, Amy hatches a desperate scheme to escape—one with devastating consequences that will echo through the centuries…

Present Day: When Lizzie Kingdom is forced to withdraw from the public eye in a blaze of scandal, it seems her life is over. But she’s about to encounter a young man, Johnny Robsart, whose fate will interlace with hers in the most unexpected of ways. For Johnny is certain that Lizzie is linked to a terrible secret dating back to Tudor times. If Lizzie is brave enough to go in search of the truth, then what she discovers will change the course of their lives forever.

About the Author

USA Today bestselling author Nicola Cornick has written over thirty historical romances for Harlequin and HQN Books. She has been nominated twice for a RWA RITA Award and twice for the UK RNA Award. She works as a historian and guide in a seventeenth century house. In 2006 she was awarded a Masters degree with distinction from Ruskin College, Oxford, where she wrote her dissertation on heroes.

Excerpt

Copyright © Nicola Cornick.

PROLOGUE

Amy Robsart, Cumnor Village

They came for me one night in the winter of 1752 when the ice was on the pond and the trees bowed under the weight of the hoar frost. There were nine priests out of Oxford, garbed all in white with tapers in hand. Some looked fearful, others burned with a righteous fervour because they thought they were doing the Lord’s work. All of them looked cold, huddled within their cassocks, the one out ahead gripping the golden crucifix as though it were all that stood between him and the devil himself.

The villagers came out to watch for a while, standing around in uneasy groups, their breath like smoke on the night air, then the lure of the warm alehouse called them back and they went eagerly, talking of uneasy ghosts and the folly of the holy men in thinking they could trap my spirit.

The hunt was long. I ran through the lost passageways of Cumnor Hall with the priests snapping at my heels and in the end, exhausted and vanquished, my ghost sank into the dark pool. They said their prayers over me and returned to their cloisters and believed the haunting to be at an end.

Yet an unquiet ghost is not so easily laid to rest. They had trapped my wandering spirit but I was not at peace. When the truth is concealed the pattern will repeat. The first victim was Amyas Latimer, the poor boy who fell to his death from the tower of the church where my body was buried. Then there was the little serving girl, Amethyst Green, who tumbled from the roof of Oakhangar Hall. Soon there will be another. If no one prevents it, I know there will be a fourth death and a fifth, and on into an endless future, the same pattern, yet different each time, a shifting magic lantern projecting the horror of that day centuries ago.

There is only one hope.

I sense her presence beside me through the dark. Each time it happens she is there too, in a different guise, like me. She is my nemesis, the arch-enemy. Yet she is the only one who can free me and break this curse. In the end it all depends on her and in freeing my spirit I sense she will also free her own.

Elizabeth.

I met her only a handful of times in my life. She was little but she was fierce, always, fierce enough to survive against the odds, a fighter, clever, ruthless, destined always to be alone. We could never have been friends yet we are locked together in this endless dance through time.

I possessed the one thing she wanted and could not have and in my dying I denied it to her forever. For a little while I thought that would be enough to satisfy me. Yet revenge sours and diminishes through the years. All I wish now is to be released from my pain and to ensure this can never happen again.

Elizabeth, my enemy, you are the only one who can help me now but to do that you must change, you must see that the truth needs to be told. Open your eyes. Find the light.

Social Links

Author Website: https://www.nicolacornick.co.uk
TWITTER: https://twitter.com/NicolaCornick
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/nicola.cornick/
Insta: https://www.instagram.com/nicolacornick/
Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/63843.Nicola_Cornick

Buy Links

Harlequin
Indiebound
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Books-A-Million
Google
iBooks
Kobo

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

The Red Lotus

Title:  The Red Lotus

Author:  Chris Bohjalian

Publication Information:  Doubleday. 2020. 400 pages.

ISBN:  0385544804 / 978-0385544801

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "The opposite of a hospice?"

Favorite Quote:  "But he felt a deep, numinous stitch within him as he recalled the deaths he had seen and the one he'd never get over, and the sad truth that no matter how many or how few people are with you at the end, you really do die alone."

Alexis works in an Emergency Department in New York City. That is, in fact, where she meets Austin. He comes in with a bullet wound, which is deemed a random act of a drunk individual in a bar. But was it? The story reveals that Austin may not be who or what he seems to be on the surface. At the beginning, though, he seems to be Alexis's dream and their meeting seems meant to be.

Months later, the two go on a tour of Vietnam around the Hoi An area. It is a bike tour for Austin who is an avid bicyclist. It is a bike tour in Vietnam so he can pay homage to the places his father and uncle fought in the war. During the course of the tour, Austin disappears.

Then, the mystery begins. Who was Austin? What really brought him to Vietnam? The story itself returns to New York with Alexis. Unwittingly, Alexis steps into the middle of a global thriller involving scientific research, its uses to save lives, and its potential uses for far more dangerous and lethal purposes.

Interestingly, the book title makes its way into the book in two diametrically opposite ways. One is a nod to Vietnamese belief about the red lotus:

"'My grandmother won't eat them.'

'Lotus flowers.'

'She thinks they're sacred. Especially the red lotus ... The heart. They heart a broken heart - but not medicinally. Spiritually.'"

The other is a nickname given to a lab conducting research into disease transmission and the ability to use certain rats as carriers. "They'd christened that one the red lotus, because their transgenic label rats had genes from their Vietnamese counterparts."

The book has a limited number of characters. The "who" of the good guys and the bad guys in the story is made clear early on. The "what" of the enterprise is not a surprise. The "why" of course is money. Even the "how" is easily guessed as the only clue found at the site of Austin's disappearance is a energy gel pack found in the road. The book hold true to its reference to "Occam's razor:  the most likely explanation is probably the correct explanation."

This book came out before the intensity of COVID pandemic became a reality. Reading it at this point through the lens of an actual global pandemic seems prescient. The mystery of this book is not really a mystery. It is more about following Alexis on her journey as she discovers who Austin was and what happened to him. Unfortunately, she is not always a character that I invest in or begin to care about. My favorite character of the book is the private detective for his story has the emotion that seems to be lacking in Alexis's story.

The information about how a contagion might be developed and spread is frighteningly fascinating. The details about rats, I could do without! At the same time, a book about a possible fictional pandemic becomes an escape from the real one.

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

Apeirogon

Title:  Apeirogon

Author:  Colum McCann

Publication Information:  Random House. 2020. 480 pages.

ISBN:  1400069602 / 978-1400069606

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "The hills of Jerusalem are a bath of fog."

Favorite Quote:  "It will not be over until we talk."

The word "apeirogon" itself is a mathematical concept. The etymology of the word is from the Greek words apeiros meaning infinite or boundless and gonia meaning angle. Mathematically, an apeirogon is a two-dimensional closed shape (a polygon) with a countable infinite number of sides. I am not entire sure what that means mathematically, but it gets the point across. This book is about a history and a dialogue with countless different perspectives that have to be reconciled and joined to form a whole.

This idea is captured in the structure of the book itself. The story is told in 1,000 chapters, each ranging from a few words to a few pages long. The sections turn from topic to topic, coming at the story from different angles. Each one ties into the cohesive whole.

This story is fiction but with lifetimes of history encapsulated in it. Having now read it, I want to go back and page by page look up the topics, the people and the history to try and better understand it. Countless books and articles have been written and continue to be written on this history. This fictionalized book puts them in the context of a story. The relationship between the history and the fictionalization is explained in the author's note in the book.

What is the story, you might ask? This is a story of two fathers, both of whom lost their young daughter to violence - one to a stray bullet and one to a bombing. Both girls were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Both girls were being raised in a time and place where violence unfortunately is common place. These two men, who some might say come from opposite ends of a political spectrum, have found commonality and friendship in their losses and their sorrow.

This is a story of the Palestinian and Israeli conflict and of two men - Rami Elhanan nor Bassam Aramin. Rami Elhanan - father of Smadar - is Israeli. Bassam Aramin - father of Abir - is Palestinian. A Palestinian suicide bomber was responsible for the death of thirteen-year-old Smadar Elhanan. A rubber bullet fired by an Israeli soldier killed ten-year-old Abir Aramin. United in their sorrow, the men call each other friend and brother.

They are members of the Parents Circle Families Forum. The membership of the joint Israeli-Palestinian organization is over 600 families who have lost an immediate family member to this conflict. The central tenet of the organization is that reconciliation and dialogue are the inherent foundation on which sustainable peace may one day be built.

What can I possibly say about this book other than read it.

I was educated as I looked up the myriad of things the story captures - the birds, the bullets, the Molotov Cocktail, the Parents Circle, the universal symbol of peace, and countless other details built into the story.

I was heartbroken, and I cried. As a human and as a parent, the loss of these two men is immeasurable and unending. In fact, in interviews, both men have said that they participated in the writing and that this book will keep the memory of their daughters alive. However, they are unable to read the book in entirety for it is a mirror of the searing grief they live with. The fact that these two families are but two examples of losses that extend so far is even more devastating.

I was given hope. Out of the loss of these men came not hate but friendship and dialogue. Perhaps, that light in the middle of this darkness will shine bright.

I was changed. This is a book and a story I will carry with me for a long time to come. Behind every headline I now read will be a vision of Abir and Smadar. Their deaths are the stark reality of this conflict.

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

The Forger's Daughter

Title:  The Forger's Daughter

Author:  Bradford Morrow

Publication Information:  Mysterious Press. 2020. 288 pages.

ISBN:  0802149251 / 978-0802149251

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "A scream shattered the night."

Favorite Quote:  "'At that moment, as I looked this man in the eye, I was reminded of Hanlon's razor, a philosophical notion that states one should never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity. It occurred to me just then that, conversely, one ought never attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by malice."

Disclaimer: I did not realize until after reading this book that the book is a sequel. While the book can be read on its own, I do feel like I missed connections and some of the story impact without the backstory.

Will and his wife Meghan are spending the sumner at their country house in the Rhinebeck valley 100 miles north of New York City. Meghan runs a bookstore, and Will operates a small literary imprint. Will's speciality though is literary forgery, a skills he has long since buried but most definitely not forgotten. 

A voice from the past - Henry Slader - pulls Will in again. "Had we been collaborators instead of competitors, God knows what satanic masterpieces we might have produced." Under threat, Will agrees to create a forgery of Edgar Allan Poe's Tamerlane. Tamerlane is a poem that tells the story of a Turkish conqueror. The original publication of Tamerlane and Other Poems in 1827 was only about 50 copies of about 40 pages printed under the name "A Bostonian." Edgar Allan Poe paid for the the original publication which was done by a young printer named Calvin Thomas. Currently, only twelve copies of this publication are known to exist, making it a valuable literary rarity. The last one sold in 2009 for a price of $662,500.

The story of this book goes that Henry Slader, who is Will's nemesis and the one responsible for severe injuries to Will's hand, has discovered a copy in a private collection. He wants Will to create a forgery such that the original can be "discovered" elsewhere and brought to auction with the proceeds going to all those involved in this nefarious enterprise. Will's adopted daughter Nicole gets involved for her father has taught her his skills, and the teacher has surpassed the student.

The majority of the book deals with the back and forth between Henry Slader and Will and the creation of the forgery itself. It delves into some of Will and Meghan's past. This is the piece I feel I miss out of, not having read the first book. It also provides insight into the world of rare books and the art of letterpress printing. Along with the forgery comes the creation of a fictional provenance to prove "authenticity" of the forgery. As a book lover, I find the details fascinating. Yet, it also renders the slow pace of the book.

The conclusion of the book comes at a fast pace and includes some unexpected events. A murder happens with no repercussions! Self-defense, perhaps? Or self-preservation? Either way, the characters involved are surprising; the calm way in which it is dealt is surprising; the lack of consequence is surprising; and the coverup after is surprising. It takes the book away from the world of rare books and brings it somewhere else all together. It's hard to find a protagonist to cheer for by the end unfortunately. Nevertheless, the book is an intriguing look at the world of rare books.

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

The Mystery of Henri Pick

Title:  The Mystery of Henri Pick

Author:  David Foenkinos (author). Sam Taylor (translator).

Publication Information:  Pushkin Press. 2020. 288 pages.

ISBN:  1782275827 / 978-1782275824

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "In 1971, the American writer Richard Brautigan published The Abortion:  An Historical Roman 1966, a quirky love story about a male librarian and a young woman with a spectacular body."

Favorite Quote:  "Readers always find themselves in a book, in one way or another. Reading is a completely egotistical pleasure. Unconsciously we expect books to speak to us. An author can write the most farfetched or implausible story ever, but there will still be readers who will still be readers who will say: 'I don't believe it:  you wrote the story of my life!'"

Bookstores, libraries, publishers, booksellers. The sources for published books are numerous and readily found. Through The Mystery of Henri Pick, I learn that there are places to go to find manuscripts the publishing industry has declined. In a 1971 novel titled, The Abortion:  An Historical Romance 1966, author Richard Brautigan wrote a character who works at a library of unpublished manuscripts. In 1990, Todd Lockwood brought the library's vision to life in Vermont. The library closed due to lack of funding. However, in 2010, the library was moved to Vancouver, Washington, a short distance away from where Richard Brautigan was born.

This literary history appeals to this bibliophile! It also forms the basis of The Mystery of Henri Pick. The book takes the idea of the Brautigan library and moves it to the small town of Crozon in Brittany. Delphine Despero, a literary agent, has family in the area. Her partner is an author whose one published work did not make the splash he envisioned.

In this library of forgotten books, Delphine discovers a masterpiece. She brings it to Paris and proceeds to be publish it. The stated author is a now-dead pizza chef whose family had no idea that he liked books much less that he might have written one. The family's reaction is perhaps the funniest part of the book for me.

The rest of the book, of course, is about the question of who the mysterious Henri Pick is. Is it the pizza chef? Is it someone else? Who? Now that the book is a phenomenal success, will someone else step forward to take credit? Should the financial gain from the book go to the pizza chef's family? Can someone else take credit or have things gone too far? The conclusion, when it comes, is somewhat of a surprise but then leaves the reaction that it was the only possible conclusion. The "mystery" of Henri Pick turns to not be all that much a mystery. The conclusion is a very satisfying "but, of course" as to the author's identity.

This is a book about authors, publishers, and book lovers. "According to him, it was not a question of liking or not liking to read, but of finding the book that was meant for you. Everybody could love reading, as long as they had the right book in their hands, a book that spoke to them, a book they could not bear to part with." It is a book for bibliophiles with lots of literary references, many to French literature with which I am not familiar but nevertheless. The book meanders through this world, going back and forth between characters and times and locations. The "farcical" part of the book description is very much embodied in the book. The "moving" part is much less present for me. M favorite part is actually not the story itself, but the little known history I learned about the Brautigan Library.

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

Creatures

Title:  Creatures

Author:  Crissy Van Meter

Publication Information:  Algonquin Books. 2020. 272 pages.

ISBN:  9781643750835

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley and a publisher's blog tour free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "There is a dead whale."

Favorite Quote:  "There are so many things I never said, because how can you say all the things when no one is ever listening?"

***** BLOG TOUR *****

Review

"I guess we are doing our best, little creature." So says a father to his daughter. This book is the daughter's story. It is a stream of consciousness flow through her memories and her knowledge. It jumps across time and place. It jumps from topic to topic sometimes with no warning. It is not the easiest track to follow, but somehow it all works. I am not even sure why, but the book draws me in to this woman's life, and I keep turning pages, wanting to know more.

The book begins the night before Evangeline's wedding. She has had and continues to have an unusual life. She is brought up and continues to live on a small island. She studies marine life. Her father is (was?) a drug-dealing alcoholic known for his special variety of weed - Winter Wonderland. "I never felt unloved, though he was not always capable of defining anything like love." Her mother is a part of her life but at the same time appears to have walked away from her. "My mother ... loves to be needed. These moments of brokenness seem to make her feel better about herself, her life. These chances make her feel like a mother again. I never feel like a daughter."

The book begins the night before the wedding and yet then leads to musing many years into the marriage - thoughts of love, infidelity, and the things that make a marriage last. "I want to talk about Liam. About our most-of-the-time happiness, how I'm afraid I'll lose him somedays, too, because I don't know what it's like to keep things."

This book, with its jumps, its at times incomplete thoughts, is more poetry than narrative. At first, I am not sure I can follow. At first, I am not sure I like it at all, especially as it begins with a vision of a dead whale beginning to decompose and be eaten by predators. I am somewhat confused at the jumps. Then, somewhere along the way, I am immersed in the experiences being described, and the image of this woman that is forming. I feel sad for the child and empathize with the woman she becomes. I see how she (and, indeed all of us) are the sum of all the experiences along the way.

One of the most memorable aspects of the book is its setting on the fictional Winter Island. The name is interesting because the island is described as "forty miles from Los Angeles on a scenic ferry ride with room for cars and concessions." Throughout the book, the atmosphere I conjure up is a forbidding, rocky place was crashing waves and impending storms. This belies the descriptions and the vibrant cover teeming with signs of life.

That is the magic of this book. The writing creates an aura and atmosphere that defies the physical descriptions and pulls you completely into its world. Yet, it does not feel forced or contrived. A beautiful and unusual debut. I look forward to reading more from the author.

About the Author

Crissy Van Meter is a writer in Los Angeles. Her writing has appeared in VICE, Catapult, Guernica, ESPN, The Hairpin, Golly, VIDA, and Bustle. She has an MFA from the New School. She teaches creative writing at The Writing Institute at Sarah Lawrence College. She is the founder of the literary project Five Quarterly, and the managing editor for Nouvella Books. She serves on the board of directors for the literary non-profit, Novelly.

About the Book

A former surf editor at ESPN and Southern California native, Van Meter deftly weaves her family history and deep California roots into this atmospheric novel set on the fictional Winter Island. She follows her protagonist, Evie, as she questions her love, her family, and her past on the night of her wedding, and through her, ultimately captures the spirit of wild California as well as her own volatile relationship with an alcoholic father to create a story that The New York Times called “a coming-of-age that is as human as it is wild… an unwavering triumph.” With phenomenal reviews from the Los Angeles Times, People Magazine, NPR, and many more, CREATURES triumphantly burst on the literary scene upon publication in January, and we are thrilled to release in paperback this fall.

Unique in its structure and written to mimic the tidal charts that Evie studies as well as the natural ebbs and flows of life, CREATURES takes readers on a provocative and mesmerizing journey as Evie is forced to reckon with her complicated upbringing in this lush, feral land off the coast of Southern California. On the eve of Evie’s wedding, a dead whale is trapped in the harbor of Winter Island, the groom may be lost at sea, and Evie’s mostly absent mother has shown up out of the blue. Evie grew up with her well-meaning but negligent father, surviving on the money he made dealing the island’s world-famous strain of marijuana, Winter Wonderland. Although he raised her with a deep respect for the elements, the sea, and the creatures living within it, he also left her to parent herself.

Van Meter based CREATURES on her own coming of age in Newport Beach. “I was asking questions about what it means to grieve, to love, to experience love informed by grief, and to love someone who isn’t always good.” She explains, “I was interested in digging into my own experiences with my father’s drug and alcohol addiction, his failures as a father, and the dichotomy of still loving him so much… And, I was interested in exploring what it means to have a treacherous past with a father like this, and what it means as an adult to decipher what it means to love, what it means to forgive.”Darkly funny and ultimately cathartic, CREATURES reveals the complexities of love and abandonment, guilt and forgiveness, betrayal and grief—and the ways in which our ability to love can be threatened if we are not brave enough to conquer the past. Melissa Broder, author of The Pisces, says, “At the intersection of the natural world and the human heart, Van Meter explores alcoholism, absence, daughterly loyalties and longing in this slim and beautiful tale that contains a whole aqueous universe in its depths.”

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.

The Wrong Kind of Woman

Title:  The Wrong Kind of Woman

Author:  Sarah McCraw Crow

Publication Information:  MIRA Books. 2020. 320 pages.

ISBN:  0778310078 / 978-0778310075

Book Source:  I received this book through NetGalley and a publisher blog tour free of cost in exchange for an honest review.

Opening Sentence:  "Oliver died the Sunday after Thanksgiving, the air heavy with snow that hadn't fallen yet."

Favorite Quote:  "The young women have made their point"

***** BLOG TOUR *****

Review

Clarendon College in New Hampshire is an all boys college with its fraternities, its old boys network, and its very clear lack of diversity. Oliver Desmarais had come to Clarendon College as a last resort when other career opportunities did not work out. He taught history. Virginia Desmarais gave up on her dreams and her pursuit of a PhD as she supported her husband's career and as cares of family took precedence. They, along with their teenage daughter Rebecca, are settled in this small town, or so it seems.

The time is 1970. One day, Oliver drops dead of an aneurysm.. What is Virginia to do? She is in need of reinventing her own life and preserving her daughters. Her vision of a cozy, family life in this small town was what she was counting on regardless of whether or not it had ever been her dream. With Oliver's death, that vision has been shattered. So, what is next?

She finds unexpected support in four women associated with the college - all outspoken and unmarried. They have been labeled the Gang of Four (a nod to the Congressional Squad of four strong, outspoken women?) by the men of the school. This group includes Louise, the one tenured female faculty member at Clarendon, which is interesting as she was also Oliver's nemesis. Yet, the women find themselves growing closer, finding commonilties where they thought differences existed.

Set in the context of the women's movement and its impending arrival at Clarendon College, this book has the potential to tell that story through the voices of these women and others at the college. The fact that these conversations are still occurring today makes the topic and the book relevant. That is the book I expect. It is not quite the book I read.

The story is told through different perspectives including Virginia, her daughter, and - the one that surprised me - Sam, a male student at Clarendon and one of Oliver's proteges. Unfortunately, the voices switch frequently and at time with no transition, making it challenging to follow and giving a scattered feel to the entire book. It was not easy to get through!

The most intriguing thought of this book is captured in its title - the wrong kind of woman. Who is that? What makes her wrong? Who decides if she is right or wrong? Louise carves out a place for herself as the only tenured faculty at an otherwise all male school. Is she wrong or does the environment label her as wrong? Virginia is reminded of her dreams and attempts to have a life beyond one just as a mother. Many in this time and place label that as wrong. Rebecca is a young woman devastated by loss but also finding her voice as a woman. Is that wrong?

So many for so long have labeled the choices of women as "wrong" if they are made for the women themselves and if they challenge existing societal boundaries. Looking around me today, it amazes me how far we have come and yet how frequently, these same conversations are taking place today. I wish the book had delivered this statement in a stronger way and in the context of a stronger story, but it is a reminder of an important statement nevertheless.

About the Book

A powerful exploration of what a woman can be when what she should be is no longer an option.

In late 1970, Oliver Desmarais drops dead in his front yard while hanging Christmas lights. In the year that follows, his widow, Virginia, struggles to find her place on the campus of the elite New Hampshire men’s college where Oliver was a professor. While Virginia had always shared her husband’s prejudices against the four outspoken, never-married women on the faculty—dubbed the Gang of Four by their male counterparts—she now finds herself depending on them, even joining their work to bring the women’s movement to Clarendon College.

Soon, though, reports of violent protests across the country reach this sleepy New England town, stirring tensions between the fraternal establishment of Clarendon and those calling for change. As authorities attempt to tamp down “radical elements,” Virginia must decide whether she’s willing to put herself and her family at risk for a cause that had never felt like her own.

Told through alternating perspectives, The Wrong Kind of Woman is an engrossing story about finding the strength to forge new paths, beautifully woven against the rapid changes of the early ‘70s.

About the Author

Sarah McCraw Crow grew up in Virginia but has lived most of her adult life in New Hampshire. Her short fiction has run in Calyx, Crab Orchard Review, Good Housekeeping, So to Speak, Waccamaw, and Stanford Alumni Magazine. She is a graduate of Dartmouth College and Stanford University, and is finishing an MFA degree at Vermont College of Fine Arts. When she's not reading or writing, she's probably gardening or snowshoeing (depending on the weather).

Social Links

Author website: https://sarahmccrawcrow.com/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/sarahmcrow?lang=en
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sarahmccrawcrow/
Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/15502401.Sarah_McCraw_Crow

Buy Links

Amazon 
Barnes & Noble
IndieBound 
Books-A-Million

Please share your thoughts and leave a comment. I would love to "talk" to you.